Человечек несёт поднос с оранжевыми пирожками к столу, за которым сидит неулыбчивая комиссия, на стене график с ровной линией и одной оранжевой точкой вверху

The Control Group

Fairy Tales # 39: The Control Group

The writer Probkin (the very same one, from the tale “Permission”) signed up for a big scientific study. The scientists were looking for people who would learn meditation for a whole year. Probkin wanted to write a book about it.

They gave him a number and said: “You are in the control group.” Probkin asked what that meant. They explained: everyone else will meditate, and you will only be measured. So that there is something to compare with.

And so it was. Everyone went on retreats, got phones with practices and sat with their eyes closed. Probkin was only measured. They took his saliva in a test tube. They put him in a scanner. They made him give talks in front of a committee in white coats that looked at him and did not smile. Several times a day his phone asked: “What are you doing right now? What are you thinking about?” Probkin answered honestly: “Giving saliva. Thinking about saliva.”

Ninety times like that. Probkin did not complain. He came on time and brought pies for the lab assistants, because they worked from morning till night. Once he told the committee in white coats a joke. The committee did not smile, they were not allowed to. But one professor coughed into his sleeve for a long time afterwards.

A year later the scientists sat down to look at the graphs. For those who meditated, everything grew where it was supposed to. In the control group nothing changed, as it was supposed to. Except for one dot. Probkin’s dot for kindness went up, higher than everyone else’s.

The scientists counted three times. Then they called Probkin and asked what he had been doing all year. Probkin answered: “Nothing. I was being measured.” The scientists asked: “And the pies?” Probkin shrugged: “Well, the pies. You were working the whole year.”

The scientists wrote an article called “The Probkin Anomaly.” And Probkin had already signed up for the control group of the next study. He never wrote the book. He said he was still collecting material.


The subtext. The ReSource study led by Tania Singer (one of the articles on its results) had a control group. These people were tested for a whole year with about ninety different measures, but they were given no practices. Singer called them the real altruists: they went through all the tests and got no benefit at all. Without them the scientists would not know what meditation really does. In the real study nothing changed for them. I made up the Probkin anomaly.

Although maybe not quite. Richard Davidson and Daniel Goleman remind us in their book “Altered Traits” that every experience changes the brain, and what we repeat becomes a trait of character. Probkin did not meditate. But ninety times in a row he came to a place where nothing was promised to him, and brought pies to people who were tired.

In Buddhism this is called the paramita of generosity, dana. It is the first of the six qualities that a bodhisattva develops. What matters in it is not the size of the gift, but that it is given without counting on a reward. You can give money, time, attention, a pie. In the Buddhist understanding of karma, each such action leaves a trace in the mind, like a footpath. Walk it ninety times, and the footpath becomes a road. Try this week to bring someone your own “pie” once, just like that. And do not watch the graph.


Discover more from AMNIMAKEN – Wind & Mind

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Мои сказки часто рождаются из того, что происходит вокруг меня или во мне. Хотите получать их сразу после выхода? Подпишитесь.

My tales are often born from what happens around me or within me. Would you like to get them as soon as they are published? Subscribe.

Leave a Reply